Upvotes and Downvotes for Facebook Posts – Some Thoughts

This is another of those posts that I wrote up a little while again on my phone (something I do quite often whist commuting etc.) but had problems uploading from there – sadly the WordPress app for iPhone seems a little glitchy these days! So in a few respects it’s a little out of date, but I’d like to have it up here anyway.

Upvotes and Downvotes for Facebook Posts – Some Thoughts

Facebook’s Up and Downvote Tools for Comments are Now Available to More Users https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/facebooks-up-and-downvote-tools-for-comments-are-now-available-to-more-use/522470/ via socialmedia2day

Facebook is deciding to model itself on Reddit then? I have thoughts about this.

This system depends on users deciding that comments aren’t or are of value – so whether or not the system works as intended (spammy or useless content at the bottom, ‘good’ content at the top) on this will depend entirely on the type of people that are engaged with a particular post or page. Some communities will absolutely work this way, but this article already points out some issues of ‘gamifying comments’ – putting something on there that is sure to score points even if it’s not relevant to the post, as well as critical comments rising to the top, to the detriment of brands. I would also argue that the reverse of this – critical comments being downvoted even if they are reasonable and the page owner needs to see them, can be an issue of close-knit Facebook communities.

Also, while very little of Facebook’s content is chronological any more (frequently to its detriment) having comments move around could make attempts at response or conversation more confusing, which won’t help post engagement or moderation.


Pinterest is powerful, why aren’t people interested in that?

In the business/marketing press, you get articles like this one all the time – https://www.socialmediatoday.com/news/pinterest-is-growing-faster-than-twitter-and-snapchat-and-offers-significa/524417/

It’s pretty common knowledge that Pinterest is a hugely important and influential social media platform. The user base is huge, and it is tailor-made for selling, from wall-paper to workout plans. The search function and related content algorithms work really well, you can build communities… it’s sort of the holy grail of social media in those respects.

Now, I’m always checking the mainstream press for articles on social media etc., and there’s never any shortage of them. But while reading the article posted above, it did occur to me that you rarely hear about Pinterest in the mainstream press, despite its size and importance. I’m wondering now why that is. Of course, it hasn’t yet had the kind of data scandals of Facebook, or community management failures of Twitter, but I have to speculate whether it has more to do with Pinterest’s heavily female user-base, versus the male-dominated world of tech journalists (who likely don’t use it.) These kind of biases crop up so often, after all. It just makes you think.



Screaming above the White Noise

(Note: this is a blog post I wrote a few weeks back, but the WordPress app decided to lose it entirely! Still, I wanted to get these thoughts out here.)

Recently, I posted the below on Twitter, referencing this particular article about Twitter bots.

Now, not all bots are bad, many were created for very good, or at least harmless reasons, for example, I follow a bot that tweets a graph of local river levels every few hours, and another that generates fictional museum exhibition names.

However, if when such a high number of accounts are bots, it starts to make the entire site useless. As the original article states, it makes Twitter engagement analytics pointless- how can you prove a real human being liked or retweeted your tweets? How can you prove growth? There are research issues to consider to – at University I did quite a bit of work on mapping Twitter connections – this was in the earlier days of academic research on social media and Twitter was quite a different beast then. Connection-mapping techniques would produce seriously flawed data in today’s Twittersphere, when mindless machine accounts are linking ‘real’ accounts up. Either Twitter, or research techniques, will have to change at a fundamental level.

Google for Business Notes

What I’ve been up to for the past few weeks…

So off the back of my last Future Learn course on Digital Analysis, I’ve started a new similar one, though it mostly goes over material that I’ve done before as in the Learning Online course, so this time I’m not going to put notes online for it.

However, I have been taking some time to watch some new Google for Business videos on YouTube, and I have a bunch of notes from the one below which that I wanted to get up here.

Google search – Making use of all your business tools

As a business, you should aim to be found locally. Optimise for mobile – 80% of all Google searches are on mobile and is no divide by age etc. anymore. Everyone is using mobile.

  • Your site needs to be speedy. Searches need to be quick paced or you will lose people mid-search.
  • Check your keywords – are you set up to be easily found.

People like to buy from/work with local businesses and this is why ‘Google my Business’ is really important as it shows you on maps and on reviews which really affects how people find you.

  • Google posts put direct info to customers
  • People live online and need live updates
  • This also improves your organic search

You will need to verify and take control of your listings

  • It’s better for you, better for customers, better for Google too
  • Ensure it suits your brand and is consistent with your tone of voice
  • Original content in your Google listings will help with all this

Put the most important info first on your site – think hard about heading and title.

  • Small image files for quick load times!!

Vision, Purpose, Value, Passion

Are these four things communicated in your site?

Remember who your target audience is, how will they search your site?

Important details for a mobile site

  • Small dropdown
  • Big buttons
  • Easy search system – make it clear and simple
  • Form filling out needs to be simple and easy on a small screen
  • Test your site for speed




Future Learn Digital Analysis Notes for Week Two

This was only a two week short course, but the same provider is running a number of other free courses via Future Learn that I will be looking at! Though I only ended up writing a small amount of notes, it was still a great, quick way to keep myself refreshed on marketing and research techniques, some of which I might need to use in my job very soon.

Week two: Segmentation

This is splitting your followers into groups according to their behaviours and preferences in order to market the right products to them.

In order to build these segments and to analyse whether they are working for you, you have to build context into your data, by creating both internal and external benchmarks, so you can compare your current success both to previous data and to the success other your competitors.

  • Missions statements, a successful company generally has a customer-oriented one
  • A strategy should be focussed on the specifics of the business and what makes it unique
  • KPIs need to be tangible measurements and numbers, relevant to your strategy
  • Once you know how a customer came to your company (via an offer, website etc) you can start to build a profile and segment your demographics

There will always be challenges in acquiring data – some of it may be incomplete or wrong, so try to focus on the overall pattern and what it tells you.

Future Learn Digital Analysis Notes for Week One

I’m back on the Future Learn train again! This time, I’m taking a short fortnight-long course in Digital Analytics, and as always I’ve been making notes for a blog post out of the first week of course material.


Data is everything that you collect as research, but analytics are primarily concerned with the numbers.

The power of digital analytics is mostly in measuring behaviour. There has been an explosion of data as it is much easier to collect and store with modern computers.

There are four types of analysis.

Descriptive –> What has happened?
Diagnostic –> Why has it happened?
Predictive –> What will happen?
Prescriptive –> What can happen?

We have analytics in many areas now that we didn’t have before, and we have improved our techniques in many areas. Knowing where your business is up to enables you to make better business decisions based on quantifiable facts.

To use analytics effectively, you need a definitive problem and an set of answers, as well as a defined measure of success.


A key website metric for businesses is of course conversions – which the course defines as

An activity on your site that is important to the success of your business

This is more than how many people look at your site, it is how they engage with it. These metrics indicate what is and isn’t working in your website and marketing strategy.

The course defines two types of conversion – micro and macro.

Micro Macro
Following on twitter Purchasing a product

Metrics need to be continually reviews and checked over to ensure that you are still getting the right answers and acting on them – it is a process of constant improvement.

Finding a Balance

One of the most important recent parts of digital marketing, at least as far as I’ve found, is finding the balance between putting your eggs in too few or too many baskets.

There’s plenty of evidence that having too many social media platforms, websites, basically digital spaces in general, means that your general content and engagement will suffer because you can’t possibly be active and interesting on that many sites. It also simply isn’t worth the time spent to maintain small groups followers and communities across many platforms when you could have a larger group on two or three.

However, there is the problem that if you use one platform that works well for you, you’re then at the mercy of that site and any changes to that site could make you inflexible. For example, recent  companies, political parties etc. have been complaining about how the changes to Facebook to promote more content from friends and families instead of brands.  Where they have been used to spending vast amounts of money to good effect, the changes have made it much harder to run good marketing campaigns. No doubt this is make many people look harder at alternative options, which is fine if you already have an organic base of followers elsewhere to start with, starting is scratch is difficult and takes time.